08/26/2026
I speak about this often because I lived it.
I played recreational soccer all the way through 8th grade. Back then, before we had all of the travel teams, clubs, leagues, and options that exist today, there was real value to rec soccer. There was a strong pool of players, competition, and an environment where kids could learn the game and develop before feeling like they had to move on to something bigger.
I didn't make my local travel team at U9, U10, or U11. And back then, we had both A and B teams at those age groups. That alone tells you how many players were coming out for travel teams and how deep the player pool was at the recreational level.
I eventually made the local travel team, and after a couple of seasons, I outgrew that environment and was invited to play in a much higher-level competitive environment. The timing worked out because my home travel team had reached that age where teams sometimes start to fold because of a lack of committed players.
At that point, my parents were driving nearly two hours to find the right environment for me. But that was after years of playing locally, learning the game, developing the basics, and building a genuine love for soccer.
Fast forward to today, and we're seeing 9- and 10-year-olds traveling two hours for games.
Somewhere along the way, many recreational organizations lost some of the value they once held. Instead of rec being a place where players can build their foundation, learn the basics, develop confidence, and most importantly, develop a pure enjoyment of the game, we're seeing players pushed into travel soccer before some of those foundations have even been established.
I'm certainly not against travel soccer. There is absolutely a time and place for higher levels of competition, and players should have opportunities to move into environments that challenge them when they're ready for it.
But travel soccer shouldn't have to replace quality recreational soccer.
We need to bring value back to the grassroots level so that families don't feel like their 9-year-old has to travel two hours away just to receive quality coaching, meaningful development, and a good soccer experience.
‘Travel sports,’ a term that has come to encompass all sorts of private teams, leagues, and clubs, used to be for the truly exceptional young athlete. Now, they’re for anyone willing to pay — an expensive, exhausting commitment that has become popular not necessarily because millions of parents want them for their children but because it can feel like there’s no other choice. Rec programs are underfunded and struggle to compete with for-profit leagues for prime field, rink, and court times. And the level of play is diluted, often very early, as travel teams are incentivized to enroll children at young ages.
Around 5 million children in the U.S. now compete on travel teams. Parents find themselves trapped. They know the benefits of sports and want that for their children, yet giving it to them often means buying into a sports ecosystem that’s inherently flawed. As the pay-to-play model increasingly takes hold, so does the idea that kids should start competing at younger and younger ages, risking their sense of self along with their shoulders and ACLs.
“I never want my kids to look back and say I didn’t do everything I could to help them live their dreams,” a mother of three soccer players said. She’s hired professional photographers to take action shots for her 12- and 13-year-olds’ Instagram accounts — the platform has become a recruiting tool — and they’ve both asked her to pay for personal trainers.
“I think the word isn’t ‘specialize’; you are ‘professionalizing’ your kid early. You are exposing them to everything professionals have to deal with — I’m talking injury, time, schedule, everything,” said John Van Benschoten, a former MLB player and travel-baseball coach.
It makes one ask: All this for what? And for whom? Read Caitlin Moscatello’s cover story on how travel leagues have made youth sports more expensive, hypercompetitive, and all-consuming — and the investors who are making a killing: https://nymag.visitlink.me/fEw_Lb