Too Pretty To Eat

Too Pretty To Eat

Share

Custom sugar cookies that are too pretty to eat, but too yummy to not!

Photos from Too Pretty To Eat's post 07/04/2026

250 years of independence from a king. Resist, because this constitution won't uphold itself!

Photos from Too Pretty To Eat's post 06/30/2026

Now, unless you're new here, you know how much I love a good baby shower order...and THIS was a GOOD baby shower order! Besides the fact that I have known this Mommy-to-Be since before the cruise she took as a teenager where she met the Daddy-to-Be, the theme was everything - classic storybooks!
Thank goodness it was summer break, because this set of five dozen took literal days. Lots of royal icing transfers, hand painting, gold painting, and writing. I love the way they turned out, and was so glad I was able to take the order.
Congratulations Tori and Will - Baby Annabeth is sure to be so loved!

Photos from Too Pretty To Eat's post 06/28/2026

Ack! Ready to post my latest order and realized I had missed one last grad order. These guys celebrated another college Master's graduation. Forks up!

Photos from Too Pretty To Eat's post 06/06/2026

One more set of twins graduating this season, and my only non-Gilbert high school this year. Some traditional grad designs mixed with a couple things that make these ladies unique. On to big things!

Photos from Too Pretty To Eat's post 06/04/2026

Traditional grad designs, but the grad herself is gluten-free. Since my cookie kitchen normally does nothing but bake up gluten, I can't promise a completely risk-free product. I do, however, do my best to make sure everything I use is thoroughly cleaned ahead of time and kept separate throughout the whole baking and decorating process. Congratulations, Madison, the last of this year's former Falcon grads!

Photos from Too Pretty To Eat's post 06/03/2026

Okay, so grad cookies, but make them prettier than grad cookies. 😉 Breaking up my Gilbert High color palette a bit with a softer, more feminine graduation set. I've watched this grad grow from a teeny tiny preschooler to a gorgeous and capable young woman. Congratulations, Olivia!

Photos from Too Pretty To Eat's post 05/30/2026

Most of my high school graduation orders this year were all for the same school, but none were identical. This first client wanted to add a fun spin - school colors but no cap, gown, or diploma cookies. And my first of two sets of twin cookies this season! I love how these turned out. So fun!

Photos from Too Pretty To Eat's post 05/30/2026

Okay, okay....I guess since I just finished decorating the last of the grad orders, I had better get to posting the in between ones! These guys headed across the country earlier this month to celebrate a college grad at an HBCU in North Carolina - Johnson C. Smith University. It's always fun to see my cookies travel so far!

Photos from Too Pretty To Eat's post 05/09/2026

The first grad order of the season went out the door last weekend. Congratulations, Master Pam!
This is definitely my busy season, and this year I have more than 20 dozen in custom orders for the month of May! (And, in case you're wondering, the answer is no. I am no longer taking graduation orders for this season. I still teach full time, so this is me maxed out.)

Photos from Too Pretty To Eat's post 05/09/2026

A stogie and a brew before I say I do! After making the cookies for the bride's bachelorette weekend, I was then enlisted to follow up with groomsmen gifts. Twelve groomsmen is a lot of testosterone in one place!

Want your business to be the top-listed Gym/sports Facility in Gilbert?

Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Location

Telephone

Website

Address


Gilbert, AZ
85295