05/06/2026
Day 7 29/05/26– New Hailey & Skelmorlie Double Header
Like any good thing in life, the best things come in twos.
After several days fishing around Scotland, there were two fisheries that had really stood out from the crowd — New Hailey and Skelmorlie. Both had delivered fantastic sport, both had fish willing to feed on the surface, and both had left us wanting more.
So rather than trying to choose between them, we did the sensible thing.
We fished both.
New Hailey – The Morning Session
We arrived at New Hailey just before 8am and were greeted by the caretaker, Alistair. After a bit of banter and Alistair giving W***y some abuse about local lingo and wind directions, we got ourselves organised and headed for the water.
The conditions couldn't have been more different from the previous five days. Gone was the relentless sunshine. Instead, we had cloud cover and a brisk south-westerly breeze pushing across the lake.
What a difference.
The first thing that caught the eye was the concentration of fish feeding along the calmer water near the dam wall. There were trout everywhere, packed into the area and actively feeding on insects being pushed along by the wind. The water looked alive. Olives were hatching steadily and the trout were chasing them down as they emerged through the surface film. Some fish were slashing at them, others were sipping them delicately, while the occasional trout launched itself clear of the water in pursuit of an unlucky insect. It was fantastic to watch. Even better when you managed to cover a fish properly and were rewarded with a confident take.
Well... mostly.
It wasn't exactly "wham, bam, thank you ma'am."
More often it was:
Cover a fish. Rejected. Cover it again. Tiny twitch. Small movement. Then a reaction take from the trout. Whatever the reason, it was working.
Geordie was first off the mark using one of his latest prototype flies. As usual, that became a source of amusement amongst the rest of us. Prototype flies are always a contentious subject when somebody starts catching on them, but seeing as I'm guilty of exactly the same behaviour myself, I simply smiled and kept my opinions to myself. Within ten minutes Geordie had landed the first fish of the session. It didn't take long before the rest of the team joined the action. Soon there were fish being hooked all around the lake, with double and even triple hook-ups happening at various points around the bank. It genuinely looked like it might become one of those ridiculous fish bonanza days.
Unfortunately, my own fishing was interrupted when my brother needed a hand with a job back home. With no laptop available, I made a quick retreat to the digs, helped him out and eventually returned to the fishery. I expected to find everyone miles ahead and well into double figures. To my surprise, the fishing had remained consistent but so had the refusals. The fish were feeding hard but were still proving selective. Back at my original spot, I spent a while simply watching the water. Olives danced across the surface while trout slurped them down and occasionally launched clear of the water trying to drown them before returning to mop up the casualties. It looked like something out of the movie Jaws. The challenge wasn't finding fish. The challenge was convincing them that your artificial offering was worth taking instead of the thousands of naturals around them. I initially enjoyed some success with a dry olive pattern, but things improved dramatically when I switched to an emerging olive pattern and a small copper buzzer. Rather than fishing static, I found sharp little jerks and pulls worked best, almost like fishing a tiny lure. For whatever reason, it triggered an aggressive response and I was getting follows, takes or hook-ups almost every cast. At one point a young local angler informed me the insects were mayflies. I wasn't about to argue. He had his name for them, I had mine, and either way the trout seemed more interested in eating them than discussing entomology.
By 1:30pm Pops had already begun gravitating towards the hut, convinced rain was coming and determined not to get his gear wet before our next destination. I wasn't interested in leaving. The agreed departure time was 3pm and I intended to fish every last minute. Eventually the clock won the argument, and at 3pm we packed up and said farewell to Senga and the fishery.
One thing was certain.
New Hailey had earned its place firmly on the return list.
Skelmorlie – The Evening Session
We arrived at Skelmorlie, grabbed a few sandwiches, and headed down to the lake.
When John saw us bouncing out of the car and heading towards the hut like eager beavers, I'm not sure whether he was shocked, surprised, or both in equal measure.
The best part? The fishery was practically deserted. Whether the weather forecast had put people off or not, we weren't complaining. The conditions looked fishy, and after a bit of banter with John we picked up our evening tickets and got started.
My plan was simple. Big and bushy.
It had worked previously and with the stronger wind it seemed sensible to simply go even bigger and bushier.
W***y immediately tied on a Grunter. It didn't take long before his rod was bent into the first fish of the evening. Pops got the message and quickly followed suit. Moments later he was into a fish as well. Meanwhile I was getting plenty of interest on the Mustachio, with a few fish missing the fly before I eventually connected with my first proper customer.
That only left Geordie. Unfortunately, with a few things going on at home, George was physically present but mentally somewhere else entirely. To his credit, once he managed to switch off for a while he still picked up a few fish before deciding to call it a night early. The irony of the day arrived around 7:30pm. After spending most of the day under clouds, wind and occasional rain, the sun suddenly reappeared with a vengeance. The wind disappeared and the lake went flat calm. The calmer weather not only affected the fishing but the midges arrived in biblical numbers. Pops battled on until around 9pm, moving around the lake and missing fish almost everywhere he stopped. He was onto a winner with the w**d fly pattern and the trout certainly seemed interested. John was fascinated by the w**d fly pattern and before heading home for the evening he spent quite a while watching Pops miss fish every cast.
Meanwhile W***y was enjoying what can only be described as a red-letter evening. The only problem was he seemed determined to miss as many fish as possible. Fish after fish came short, missed the fly, or somehow escaped. Thankfully enough stayed connected to give him the honour of top rod with 12 fish to the net. We fished right through until 10pm.W***y was still catching. I continued picking away on the big dries and just before heading for the car, I managed to lose a cracking tiger trout that would have been a fitting end to the day.Some fish are simply destined to win.
Summary
If there was one takeaway from our Scottish trip, it was that New Hailey and Skelmorlie were the standout venues. Both fisheries consistently produced fish willing to feed on the surface, even under conditions that are normally considered terrible for dry fly fishing. The sport was exciting, the fish were plentiful, and both venues offered tremendous value at a time when costs seem to be rising everywhere.
Perhaps even more impressive than the fishing were the people. Senga, George and John couldn't do enough for visitors. Whether it was local advice, recommendations on where to eat, suggestions on other fisheries, or simply making anglers feel welcome, they all went above and beyond In fact, they were often recommending competing fisheries simply because they wanted visitors to enjoy the best possible fishing during their stay.
That's a rare thing these days. Some traditional lough anglers might argue the fisheries are too small, there are no boats, or that they don't present enough challenge. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. For us, however, both fisheries were so enjoyable that we felt compelled to fish them twice during the same trip. And that probably tells you everything you need to know.
Sometimes the best recommendation is simply wanting to go back before you've even left.