Retro Baker Cookie Co

Soda Pop, but make it Valentine’s 💖
K-pop Demon Hunters inspired cookies hittin’ harder than the chorus 🎶🍪
Sweet, bold, and impossible to skip—just like your favorite song 💘🥤

Cookies!

🌟🌚🌌

Finding Nemo 🪸🐟🐡

🦒🤍🩷💚💛

be my galentine 🩷🤍❤️

💙🤍❤️

Give your Valentine the gift of a cookie card. A standard sized decorated cookie on a matching card. A perfect gift to give a coworker, teacher, friend, grandparent, child, and more!
$5 each
Choose from:
🌮"Taco bout an awesome valentine" (taco)
🍕"You have a pizza my heart" (pizza)
🏈"Touchdown treat" (football helmet)
🍩"I like you a hole lot" (donut)
✏️"Love being your student" (teacher)
🦄"You're magical" (unicorn)
🖤"I tolerate you"
🦖"You're dino-mite" (dinosaur)
☕️"I love you a latte" (coffee)
🍫"Hugs and kisses" (Hershey kiss shape cookie)
🩷Personalized Sweetheart with custom name choice.



Email [email protected] or call 716-878-8821 to order. See menu for other items!

Swiftie Bracelet cookie pre-order coming soon! Comment below if you'd like a reminder!


Larger size cookie. Individual wrapped with ribbon and tag. Choose a short name or 1 word phrase such as "Bestie" "Lover" "Friends" "Swiftie"
$6 ea.

We are stocked with holiday cookies and dessertsfor easy grab and go!
Biscotti
Macaroons
Italian cookies
Bread
Cutout cookies
Hot Cocoa bombs
Cookie decorating kits
Gingerbread house kits
Cupcakes
And more!
Get it while you can!

1197 Niagara St
Open 8am-4pm W-F
8am - 2pm Sat